Sunday, March 10, 2013

Let's Talk About The League of Nations and the United Nations


The League of Nations
After the end of World War I, the need of an international body was desired in order to govern any conflicts and turmoil while keeping world peace. The League of Nations was created in hopes of providing stability to the world as the Versailles Treaty caused problems within Europe in the years following the war (League of Nations).
Proposed as part of the Fourteen Points by President Woodrow Wilson, the League of Nations was to maintain peace throughout Europe by providing a place for the countries, or actors, to talk to each other and have dialogue in order to resolve conflicts rather than go to war. In order to ensure that war would not be an option, the League had different methods of action in order to ensure world peace (U.S. Department of State).
The League had the ability to impose economic sanctions, along with the physical sanctions in order to shatter a country’s economic ability. But the problem with imposing both economic and physical sanctions was that while in the middle of rebuilding and fixing the financial structure after the war, France and Britain could not perform the sanctions necessary to affect a country’s wellbeing.
Without being able to impose the sanctions necessary to influencing a country to stop their behavior, the League did not hold the power in order to accomplish what was needed. But another weakness that kept the League from being as successful as hoped was American was unwilling to join, even though it was President Wilson’s creation.   
Even though the League was Wilson’s creation, the US Congress would not agree to join the League. Congress, controlled by the Republicans, would not see eye to eye with the Democratic president, Wilson. Other factors contributed as to why Congress vetoed the move, but the biggest was the difference in the political parties. The US did not join, along with Communist Russia. Germany was no longer considered part of the international community after the war, so the country could not join the League of Nations, but was left to brood over the outcome of the war and the Versailles Treaty.
The powers that were part of the League though, France and Britain, were too busy rebuilding after the war to pay attention to the League. With no financial or military support to offer, the League of Nations suffered with the losses, even though the League was able to handle conflicts that ended successfully.
But as the time between the First World War and the Second World War drew to a close, it became apparent that the League of Nations was not going to stop war from breaking out in Europe as France and Britain tried their best to appease Germany as America sat in its little bubble.    

The United Nations
                During World War II, it was apparent that Wilson was right. In order to establish and maintain world peace and have open dialogue, all of the actors of the world would have to unite and form some kind of international organization to promote peace and provide assistance.
                The term “United Nations” was first used by President Franklin D. Roosevelt during the Declaration by United Nations of the 1 of January 1942. At the time, twenty-six nations represented all pledged to keep fighting the Axis Powers together (Histoire, ONU, Nations Unies, Charte, Chronologie).
                After the war, in 1945, representatives of fifty countries met to draw up the United Nations Charter. Taking from proposals worked out the year before by delegates of the Soviet Union, China, and America. Signed on 26 June 1945, the Charter was ratified by the fifty countries present and Poland later, becoming part of the original member states (Histoire). 
                Much like its predecessor, the UN was created in order to prevent another world war happening, and mediate talks between two fighting countries in order to find an agreement if at all possible. The UN would also provide humanitarian relief to the nations that are in need of aid. The UN promotes and works for world peace by many different means.
                With the supporting power and military of nations throughout the world—more support than the League of Nations had. The UN has the ability to be more efficient and participate in such actions as putting up economic or physical sanctions on a country. The UN has participated in doing so with countries involved in nuclear testing—North Korea and Iran.
                The UN also works to rid the world of the nuclear weapons, including the testing and the building of the weapons. Over the decades since the first time nuclear weaponry was discovered and used, many treaties have been established, looking to prevent the spread of nuclear technology and testing. Many countries have sought to do disarm most of the weapons in order to prevent the spread and testing of weapons (UNODA).
                The UN also participates in humanitarian intervention within countries that are in need of aid. After realizing how severe human rights were being violated throughout the world, along with questioning if the UN would have the ability to interfere with the sovereignty of the affairs of a nation (Rwanda, Genocide).
                Depending on the situation, the sovereignty of a nation is not at risk when the aid is asked for, such as the Gulf War, the intervention was in the form of protecting one country from another country’s aggression. But what is to be done about countries with internal struggles? Intervening would cause a loss of sovereignty to a nation, but the rights of the citizens would be protected.
                While the UN attempts to do well, the UN also comes under fire for their actions. Some countries do not want the UN intervening within their country’s internal affairs, the UN has failed to prevent the loss of human rights within countries, and their own hesitation to “use the g-word” while discussing situations like Rwanda’s genocide.


Works Cited
"Histoire, ONU, Nations Unies, Charte, Chronologie." UN News Center. UN, n.d. Web. 10 Mar. 2013.

"League of Nations." League of Nations. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Mar. 2013.

"Milestones: 1914-1920." U.S. Department of State. Office of the Historian, n.d. Web.

"Official UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights Home Page." Official UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights Home Page. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Mar. 2013.

"Rwanda, Genocide, Hutu, Tutsi, Mass Execution, Ethnic Cleansing, Massacre, Human Rights, Victim Remembrance, Education, Africa." UN News Center. UN, n.d. Web. 10 Mar. 2013.

"UNODA - Nuclear Weapons Home." UN News Center. UN, n.d. Web. 10 Mar. 2013.


No comments:

Post a Comment